H. B. 2479
(By Delegates Compton, Leach, Hunt, Hutchins,
Hubbard, Burke and Fleischauer)
[Introduced February 14, 1995; referred to the
Committee on the Judiciary then Finance.]
A BILL to amend and reenact sections three, five, six, seven and
thirteen, article eleven-a, chapter five of the code of West
Virginia, one thousand nine hundred thirty-one, as amended,
all relating to the West Virginia Fair Housing Act; changing
references from handicap and handicapped to disability and
disabled; award of attorney fees; special fund created; use
of funds.
Be it enacted by the Legislature of West Virginia:
That sections three, five, six, seven and thirteen, article
eleven-a, chapter five of the code of West Virginia, one thousand
nine hundred thirty-one, as amended, be amended and reenacted,
all to read as follows:
ARTICLE 11A. WEST VIRGINIA FAIR HOUSING ACT.
§5-11A-3. Definitions.
As used in this article:
(a) "Commission" means the West Virginia human rights commission;
(b) "Dwelling" means any building, structure or portion
thereof which is occupied as, or designed or intended for
occupancy as, a residence or sleeping place by one or more
persons or families, and any vacant land which is offered for
sale or lease for the construction or location thereon of any
such building, structure or portion thereof;
(c) "Family" includes a single individual;
(d) "Person" includes one or more individuals, corporations,
partnerships, associations, labor organizations, legal
representatives, mutual companies, joint-stock companies, trusts,
unincorporated organizations, trustees, trustees in cases under
Title 11 of the United States Code, receivers and fiduciaries;
(e) "To rent" includes to lease, to sublease, to let and
otherwise to grant for a consideration the right to occupy
premises not owned by the occupant;
(f) "Discriminatory housing practice" means an act that is
unlawful under section five, six, seven or nineteen of this
article;
(g) "Handicap" "Disability" means, with respect to a person:
(1) A physical or mental impairment which substantially
limits one or more of such person's major life activities;
(2) A record of having such an impairment; or
(3) Being regarded as having such an impairment, but such term does not include current, illegal use of or addiction to a
controlled substance, as defined in Section 102 of the Controlled
Substances Act, Title 21, United States Code, Section 802;
(h) "Aggrieved person" includes any person who:
(1) Claims to have been injured by a discriminatory housing
practice; or
(2) Believes that such person will be injured by a
discriminatory housing practice that is about to occur;
(i) "Complainant" means the person, including the
commission, who files a complaint under section eleven of this
article;
(j) "Familial status" means:
(1) One or more individuals who have not attained the age of
eighteen years being domiciled with:
(A) A parent or another person having legal custody of such
individual or individuals; or
(B) The designee of such parent or other person having such
custody with the written permission of such parent or other
person; or
(2) Any person who is pregnant or is in the process of
securing legal custody of any individual who has not attained the
age of eighteen years;
(k) "Conciliation" means the attempted resolution of issues
raised by a complaint or by the investigation of such complaint through informal negotiations involving the aggrieved person, the
respondent and the commission;
(l) "Conciliation agreement" means a written agreement
setting forth the resolution of the issues in conciliation;
(m) "Respondent" means:
(1) The person or other entity accused in a complaint of an
unfair housing practice; and
(2) Any other person or entity identified in the course of
investigation and notified as required with respect to
respondents so identified under subsection (a), section eleven of
this article; and
(n) The term "rooming house" means a house or building where
there are one or more bedrooms which the proprietor can spare for
the purpose of giving lodgings to such persons as he chooses to
receive.
§5-11A-5. Discrimination in sale or rental of housing and other
prohibited practices.
As made applicable by section four of this article and
except as exempted by sections four and eight of this article, it
shall be unlawful:
(a) To refuse to sell or rent after the making of a bona
fide offer, or to refuse to negotiate for the sale or rental of,
or otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any person
because of race, color, religion, ancestry, sex, familial status, blindness, handicap disability or national origin;
(b) To discriminate against any person in the terms,
conditions or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling, or in
the provision of services or facilities in connection therewith,
because of race, color, religion, ancestry, sex, familial status,
blindness, handicap disability or national origin;
(c) To make, print or publish, or cause to be made, printed
or published any notice, statement or advertisement, with respect
to the sale or rental of a dwelling that indicates any
preference, limitation or discrimination based on race, color,
religion, sex, blindness, handicap disability, familial status,
ancestry or national origin, or an intention to make any such
preference, limitation or discrimination;
(d) To represent to any person because of race, color,
religion, sex, blindness, handicap disability, familial status,
ancestry or national origin that any dwelling is not available
for inspection, sale or rental when such dwelling is in fact so
available;
(e) For profit, to induce or attempt to induce any person to
sell or rent any dwelling by representations regarding the entry
or prospective entry into the neighborhood of a person or persons
of a particular race, color, religion, sex, blindness, handicap
disability, familial status, ancestry or national origin; or
(f) (1) To discriminate in the sale or rental, or to otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any buyer or
renter because of a handicap disability of: (A) That buyer or
renter; (B) a person residing in or intending to reside in that
dwelling after it is so sold, rented or made available; or (C)
any person associated with that buyer or renter.
(2) To discriminate against any person in the terms,
conditions or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling, or in
the provision of services or facilities in connection with such
dwelling, because of a handicap disability of: (A) That person;
(B) a person residing in or intending to reside in that dwelling
after it is so sold, rented or made available; or (C) any person
associated with that person.
(3) For purposes of this subdivision, discrimination
includes:
(A) A refusal to permit, at the expense of the handicapped
disabled person, reasonable modifications of existing premises
occupied or to be occupied by such person if such modifications
may be necessary to afford such person full enjoyment of the
premises, except that, in the case of a rental, the landlord may
where it is reasonable to do so condition permission for a
modification on the renter agreeing to restore the interior of
the premises to the condition that existed before the
modification, reasonable wear and tear excepted;
(B) A refusal to make reasonable accommodations in rules, policies, practices or services when such accommodations may be
necessary to afford such person equal opportunity to use and
enjoy a dwelling; or
(C) In connection with the design and construction of
covered multifamily dwellings for first occupancy after the date
that is thirty months after the date of enactment of the West
Virginia fair housing act, a failure to design and construct
those dwellings in such a manner that:
(i) The public use and common use portions of such dwellings
are readily accessible to and usable by handicapped disabled
persons;
(ii) All the doors designed to allow passage into and within
all premises within such dwellings are sufficiently wide to allow
passage by handicapped disabled persons in wheelchairs; and
(iii) All premises within such dwellings contain the
following features of adaptive design: (I) An accessible route
into and through the dwelling; (II) light switches, electrical
outlets, thermostats and other environmental controls in
accessible locations; (III) reinforcements in bathroom walls to
allow later installation of grab bars; and (IV) usable kitchens
and bathrooms such that an individual in a wheelchair can
maneuver about the space.
(4) Compliance with the appropriate requirements of the
American national standard for buildings and facilities providing accessibility and usability for physically handicapped disabled
people, commonly cited as ANSI A117.1, suffices to satisfy the
requirements of subparagraph (3)(C)(iii) of this subdivision.
(5) (A) If a unit of general local government has
incorporated into its laws the requirements set forth in
subparagraph (3)(C) of this subdivision, compliance with such
laws shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements of that
subparagraph.
(B) The commission or unit of general local government may
review and approve newly constructed covered multifamily
dwellings for the purpose of making determinations as to whether
the design and construction requirements of subparagraph (3)(C)
of this subdivision are met.
(C) The commission shall encourage, but may not require,
units of local government to include in their existing procedures
for the review and approval of newly constructed covered
multifamily dwellings, determinations as to whether the design
and construction of such dwellings are consistent with
subparagraph (3)(C) of this subdivision, and may provide
technical assistance to units of local government and other
persons to implement the requirements of such subparagraph.
(D) Nothing in this article shall be construed to require
the commission to review or approve the plans, designs or
construction of all covered multifamily dwellings to determine whether the design and construction of such dwellings are
consistent with the requirements of subparagraph (3)(C) of this
subdivision.
(6) (A) Nothing in paragraph (5) of this subdivision shall
be construed to affect the authority and responsibility of the
commission or a local public agency to receive and process
complaints or otherwise engage in enforcement activities under
this article.
(B) Determinations by a unit of general local government
under subparagraphs (5) (A) and (B) of this subdivision shall not
be conclusive in enforcement proceedings under this article.
(7) As used in this section, the term "covered multifamily
dwellings" means: (A) Buildings consisting of four or more units
if such buildings have one or more elevators; and (B) ground
floor units in other buildings consisting of four or more units.
(8) Nothing in this article shall be construed to invalidate
or limit any law of this state or any political subdivision
hereof that requires dwellings to be designed and constructed in
a manner that affords handicapped disabled persons greater access
than is required by this article.
(9) Nothing in this section requires that a dwelling be made
available to an individual whose tenancy would constitute a
direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals or
whose tenancy would result in substantial physical damage to the property of others. The burden of proving such threat to health
or safety or the likelihood of such damage shall be upon the
respondent.
§5-11A-6. Discrimination in residential real estate-related
transactions.
(a) It shall be unlawful for any person or other entity
whose business includes engaging in residential real
estate-related transactions to discriminate against any person in
making available such a transaction or in the terms or conditions
of such a transaction because of race, color, religion, sex,
blindness, handicap disability, familial status, ancestry or
national origin.
(b) As used in this section, the term "residential real
estate-related transaction" means any of the following:
(1) The making or purchasing of loans or providing other
financial assistance: (A) For purchasing, constructing,
improving, repairing or maintaining a dwelling; or (B) secured by
residential real estate; or
(2) The selling, brokering or appraising of residential real
property.
(c) Nothing in this article prohibits a person engaged in
the business of furnishing appraisals of real property to take
into consideration factors other than race, color, religion,
national origin, ancestry, sex, blindness, handicap disability or familial status.
§5-11A-7. Discrimination in provision of brokerage services.
It shall be unlawful to deny any person access to or
membership or participation in any multiple listing service, real
estate broker's organization or other service, organization or
facility relating to the business of selling or renting
dwellings, or to discriminate against him or her in the terms or
conditions of such access, membership or participation on account
of race, color, religion, sex, blindness, handicap disability
familial status, ancestry or national origin.
§5-11A-13. Election of remedies; administrative hearings and
discovery; exclusivity of remedies; final orders;
review by commission; judicial review; remedies;
attorney fees.
(a) When a charge is filed under section eleven of this
article, a complainant, a respondent or an aggrieved person on
whose behalf the complaint was filed, may elect to have the
claims asserted in that charge decided in a civil action under
subsection (o) of this section in lieu of a hearing under
subsection (b) of this section. The election must be made not
later than twenty days after the receipt by the electing person
of service under section eleven of this article or, in the case
of the commission, not later than twenty days after such service.
The person making such election shall give notice of doing so to the commission and to all other complainants and respondents to
whom the charge relates.
(b) If an election is not made under subsection (a) of this
section with respect to a charge filed under section eleven of
this article, the commission shall provide an opportunity for a
hearing on the record with respect to a charge issued under said
section. The commission shall delegate the conduct of a hearing
under this section to an administrative law judge who shall be a
licensed attorney. The administrative law judge shall conduct
the hearing at a place in the county in which the discriminatory
housing practice is alleged to have occurred or is about to
occur.
(c) At a hearing under this section, each party may appear
in person, be represented by counsel, present evidence,
cross-examine witnesses and obtain the issuance of subpoenas
under section twelve of this article. Any aggrieved person may
intervene as a party in the proceeding. The rules of evidence
apply to the presentation of evidence in such hearing as they
would in a civil action in the circuit courts of this state. The
case in support of the complaint shall be presented before the
administrative law judge by the attorney general.
(d) (1) Discovery in administrative proceedings under this
section shall be conducted as expeditiously and inexpensively as
possible, consistent with the need of all parties to obtain relevant evidence.
(2) A hearing under this section shall be conducted as
expeditiously and inexpensively as possible, consistent with the
needs and rights of the parties to obtain a fair hearing and a
complete record.
(3) The commission shall, not later than one hundred eighty
days after the date of enactment of this subsection, issue rules
to implement this subsection.
(e) Any resolution of a charge before a final order under
this section shall require the consent of the aggrieved person on
whose behalf the charge is issued.
(f) An administrative law judge may not continue
administrative proceedings under this section regarding any
alleged discriminatory housing practice after the beginning of
the trial of a civil action commenced by the aggrieved party
under an act of Congress or a state law seeking relief with
respect to that discriminatory housing practice.
(g) (1) The administrative law judge shall commence the
hearing under this section no later than one hundred twenty days
following the issuance of the charge, unless it is impracticable
to do so. If the administrative law judge is unable to commence
the hearing within one hundred twenty days after the issuance of
the charge, the administrative law judge shall notify the
commission, the aggrieved person on whose behalf the charge was filed and the respondent in writing of the reasons for not doing
so.
(2) The administrative law judge shall make findings of fact
and conclusions of law within sixty days after the end of the
hearing under this section, unless it is impracticable to do so.
If the administrative law judge is unable to make findings of
fact and conclusions of law within such period, or any succeeding
sixty-day period thereafter, the administrative law judge shall
notify the commission, the aggrieved person on whose behalf the
charge was filed and the respondent in writing of the reasons for
not doing so.
(3) If the administrative law judge finds that a respondent
has engaged or is about to engage in a discriminatory housing
practice, such administrative law judge shall promptly issue an
order for such relief as may be appropriate, which may include
actual damages suffered by the aggrieved person and injunctive or
other equitable relief. Such order may, to vindicate the public
interest, assess a civil penalty against the respondent: (A) In
an amount not exceeding ten thousand dollars if the respondent
has not been adjudged to have committed any prior discriminatory
housing practice; (B) in an amount not exceeding twenty-five
thousand dollars if the respondent has been adjudged to have
committed one other discriminatory housing practice during the
five-year period ending on the date of the filing of this charge; and (C) in an amount not exceeding fifty thousand dollars if the
respondent has been adjudged to have committed two or more
discriminatory housing practices during the seven-year period
ending on the date of the filing of this charge; except that if
the acts constituting the discriminatory housing practice that
are the object of the charge are committed by the same natural
person who has been previously adjudged to have committed acts
constituting a discriminatory housing practice, then the civil
penalties set forth in subparagraphs (B) and (C) may be imposed
without regard to the period of time within which any subsequent
discriminatory housing practice occurred.
(4) No such order shall affect any contract, sale,
encumbrance or lease consummated before the issuance of such
order and involving a bona fide purchaser, encumbrancer or tenant
without actual notice of the charge filed under this article.
(5) In the case of an order with respect to a discriminatory
housing practice that occurred in the course of a business
subject to licensing or regulation by a governmental agency, the
commission shall, not later than thirty days after the date of
the issuance of such order or, if such order is judicially
reviewed, thirty days after such order is in substance affirmed
upon such review: (A) Send copies of the findings of fact,
conclusions of law and the order to that governmental agency; and
(B) recommend to that governmental agency appropriate disciplinary action, including, where appropriate, the suspension
or revocation of the license of the respondent.
(6) In the case of an order against a respondent against
whom another order was issued within the preceding five years
under this section, the commission shall send a copy of each such
order to the attorney general.
(7) In instances in which the attorney general renders legal
services to the commission, the attorney general is entitled to
an award of attorney's fees against any person found to be
committing an unlawful discriminatory act in the like manner as
a private attorney representing a person claiming to be aggrieved
by an unlawful discriminatory act. All money received by the
state on and after the first day of July, one thousand nine
hundred ninety-five, as a result of this provision, shall be
deposited in a special revenue fund hereby created in the state
treasury and designated "The Human Rights Commission Litigation
Fund," and such money shall be used solely for payment of fees,
costs, expenses and other charges incurred by the commission in
connection with proceedings under this article. At the close of
the fiscal year ending the thirtieth day of June, one thousand
nine hundred ninety-six, all sums in such funds in excess of one
hundred thousand dollars shall expire into the state general
revenue fund and the balance shall remain therein for
expenditure. At the close of the fiscal year ending the thirtieth day of June, one thousand nine hundred ninety-seven,
all sums in such fund in excess of one hundred seventy-five
thousand dollars shall expire in the state general revenue fund
and the balance shall remain therein for expenditure. At the
close of the fiscal year ending the thirtieth day of June, one
thousand nine hundred ninety-eight, and each year thereafter, all
sums in such fund in excess of two hundred fifty thousand dollars
shall expire into the state general revenue fund and the balance
shall remain therein for expenditure.
(7) (8) If the administrative law judge finds that the
respondent has not engaged or is not about to engage in a
discriminatory housing practice, as the case may be, such
administrative law judge shall enter an order dismissing the
charge. The commission shall make public disclosure of each such
dismissal.
(h) (1) The commission may review any finding, conclusion
or order issued under subsection (g) of this section. Such
review shall be completed not later than thirty days after the
finding, conclusion or order is so issued; otherwise the finding,
conclusion or order becomes final.
(2) The commission shall cause the findings of fact and
conclusions of law made with respect to any final order for
relief under this section, together with a copy of such order, to
be served on each aggrieved person and each respondent in the proceeding.
(i) (1) Any party aggrieved by a final order for relief
under this section granting or denying, in whole or in part, the
relief sought may obtain a review of such order under section
four, article five, chapter twenty-nine-a of this code.
(2) Notwithstanding chapter twenty-nine-a of this code,
venue of the proceeding shall be in the judicial circuit in which
the discriminatory housing practice is alleged to have occurred
and filing of the petition for review shall be not later than
thirty days after the order is entered.
(j) (1) The commission may petition the circuit court in the
circuit in which the discriminatory housing practice is alleged
to have occurred or in which any respondent resides or transacts
business for the enforcement of the order of the administrative
law judge and for appropriate temporary relief or injunctive
relief by filing in such court a written petition praying that
such order be enforced and for appropriate temporary relief or
injunctive relief.
(2) The commission shall file in court with the petition the
record in the proceeding. A copy of such petition shall be
forthwith transmitted by the clerk of the court to the parties to
the proceeding before the administrative law judge.
(k) (1) Upon the filing of a petition under subsection (i)
or (j) of this section, the court may:
(A) Grant to the petitioner, or any other party, such
temporary relief, injunction or other order as the court deems
just and proper;
(B) Affirm the order or decision of the administrative law
judge or remand the case for further proceedings. It shall
reverse, vacate or modify the order or decision of the
administrative law judge if the substantial rights of the parties
have been prejudiced because the administrative findings,
inferences, conclusions, decision or order are: (i) In violation
of constitutional or statutory provisions; or (ii) in excess of
the statutory authority or jurisdiction of the commission; or
(iii) made upon unlawful procedures; or (iv) affected by other
error of law; or (v) clearly wrong in view of the reliable,
probative and substantial evidence on the whole record; or (vi)
arbitrary or capricious or characterized by abuse of discretion
or clearly unwarranted exercise of discretion; and
(C) Enforce such order to the extent that such order is
affirmed or modified.
(2) Any party to the proceeding before the administrative
law judge may intervene in the circuit court.
(3) No objection not made before the administrative law
judge shall be considered by the court, unless the failure or
neglect to urge such objection is excused because of
extraordinary circumstances.
(4) The judgment of the circuit court shall be final unless
reversed, vacated or modified on appeal to the supreme court of
appeals of this state in accordance with the provisions of
section one, article six, chapter twenty-nine-a of this code.
(l) If no petition for review is filed under subsection (i)
of this section before the expiration of forty-five days after
the date the administrative law judge's order is entered, the
administrative law judge's findings of fact and order shall be
conclusive in connection with any petition for enforcement: (1)
Which is filed by the commission under subsection (j) of this
section after the end of such day; or (2) under subsection (m) of
this section.
(m) If before the expiration of sixty days after the date
the administrative law judge's order is entered, no petition for
review has been filed under subsection (i) of this section, and
the commission has not sought enforcement of the order under
subsection (j) of this section, any person entitled to relief
under the order may petition for a decree enforcing the order in
the circuit court for the circuit in which the discriminatory
housing practice is alleged to have occurred.
(n) The judge of the circuit court in which a petition for
enforcement is filed under subsection (l) or (m) of this section
shall forthwith enter a decree enforcing the order and shall
transmit a copy of such decree to the commission, the respondent named in the petition and to any other parties to the proceeding
before the administrative law judge. The judgment of the circuit
court shall be final unless reversed, vacated or modified on
appeal to the supreme court of appeals pursuant to section one,
article six, chapter twenty-nine-a of this code.
(o) (1) If an election is made under subsection (a) of this
section, the commission shall authorize, and not later than
thirty days after the election is made the attorney general shall
commence and maintain, a civil action on behalf of the aggrieved
person in the appropriate circuit court seeking relief under this
subsection. Venue for such civil action shall be in the circuit
court in the county in which the alleged discriminatory housing
practice occurred.
(2) Any aggrieved person with respect to the issues to be
determined in a civil action under this subsection may intervene
as of right in that civil action.
(3) In a civil action under this subsection, if the court
finds that a discriminatory housing practice has occurred or is
about to occur, the court may grant as relief any relief which a
court could grant with respect to such discriminatory housing
practice in a civil action under section fourteen of this
article. Any relief so granted that would accrue to an aggrieved
person in a civil action commenced by that aggrieved person under
said section shall also accrue to that aggrieved person in a civil action under this subsection. If monetary relief is sought
for the benefit of an aggrieved person who does not intervene in
the civil action, the court shall not award such relief if that
aggrieved person has not complied with discovery orders entered
by the court.
(p) In any administrative proceeding brought under this
section, or any court proceeding arising therefrom, or any civil
action under section fourteen of this article, the administrative
law judge or the court, as the case may be, in its discretion,
may allow a prevailing complainant a reasonable attorney's fee
and costs.
NOTE: The purpose of this bill is to change the term
"handicap" to "disability" or a person with a disability. This
does not change the definition of what constitutes a person with
a disability. This bill also includes costs and attorney fees
awarded to a special fund to pay for enforcement costs.
Strike-throughs indicate language that would be stricken
from the present law, and underscoring indicates new language
that would be added.